Review on environmental impact assessment of waste textiles and clothing recycling

doi:10.19398/j.att.202206029

Advanced Textile Technology ›› 2022, Vol. 30 ›› Issue (6): 28-36.DOI: 10.19398/j.att.202206029

• Invited Column: Bibliometric Analysis of Textile • Previous Articles Next Articles

Review on environmental impact assessment of waste textiles and clothing recycling

CHEN Shuang^1a, HUANG Qianwen^1a, LIU Can^1a, WANG Caihong^1a, WANG Luyao^1a, YE Xiangyu², WANG Laili^1a,1b

1a. School of Fashion Design & Engineering; 1b. Zhejiang Provincial Research Center of Fashion Engineering Technology, Zhejiang Sci-Tech University, Hangzhou 310018, China;
2. Zhejiang Light Industrial Products Inspection and Research Institute, Hangzhou 310018, China

Received:2022-06-14 Online:2022-11-10 Published:2022-11-16

废旧纺织品服装回收再利用环境影响评价综述

陈爽^1a, 黄倩雯^1a, 刘灿^1a, 王彩虹^1a, 王璐瑶^1a, 叶翔宇², 王来力^1a,1b

1.浙江理工大学,a.服装学院,b.浙江省服装工程技术研究中心, 杭州 31008;
2.浙江省轻工业品质量检验研究院,杭州 310018

通讯作者: 王来力,E-mail: wangll@zstu.edu.cn
作者简介:陈爽(1998—),女,山东菏泽人,硕士研究生,主要从事纺织品服装碳足迹核算与评价方面的研究。
基金资助:
浙江理工大学基本科研业务费专项项目(2021Y008),国家自然科学基金项目(71503233)

Abstract

Abstract: In order to study the environmental impact assessment of waste textiles and clothing recycling, this paper adopts CiteSpace visual literature analysis tool to conduct bibliometric analysis on the Chinese and English literature on the environmental impact assessment of waste textiles and clothing recycling, and discusses the environmental impact results of waste textiles and clothing recycling, the environmental benefit calculation of recycling, the method of environmental impact sharing, and comprehensive evaluation of environmental impact. The results show that the environmental impact is significantly different when the same waste textile is treated by different recycling processes or the waste textile is regenerated into different products. The environmental benefits of the recycling of waste textiles and clothing can be obtained through the system expansion method. Including replacement rate and quality of recycled raw materials can improve the calculation accuracy and avoid subjective evaluation of environmental benefits. The environmental benefits of the recycling of waste textiles and clothing can be reasonably shared between the two life cycles, which can benefit multiple parties and avoid double-counting of environmental benefits. The comprehensive assessment of environmental impact can be characterized by value method, scoring method and geometric area method, so as to compare the overall environmental impact of different regeneration methods.

Key words: waste textiles, recycling and reuse, system expansionmethod, allocation rules, comprehensive evaluation method

摘要： 为研究废旧纺织品服装回收再利用环境影响评价的相关问题,采用CiteSpace可视化文献分析工具,对废旧纺织品服装回收再利用环境影响评价的中英文文献进行计量分析,并讨论了废旧纺织品服装回收再利用的环境影响评价结果、再生循环的环境效益计算与分摊方法、环境影响结果综合评价等问题。结果表明:采用不同的回收工艺处理同种废旧纺织品,或将废旧纺织品再生成不同的产品,造成的环境影响具有显著差异;废旧纺织品服装再生循环的环境效益可通过扩展系统边界法进行量化,纳入再生原料的替换率和质量可提高计算精度,并可避免环境效益的主观性评价;废旧纺织品服装再生循环的环境效益在前后两个生命周期进行合理分摊,可避免环境效益的重复计算;环境影响的综合评价可实现不同再生方式环境影响的客观比较。

关键词: 废旧纺织品, 回收再利用, 扩展系统边界法, 分摊规则, 综合评价法

CLC Number:

TS102.9

CHEN Shuang, HUANG Qianwen, LIU Can, WANG Caihong, WANG Luyao, YE Xiangyu, WANG Laili. Review on environmental impact assessment of waste textiles and clothing recycling[J]. Advanced Textile Technology, 2022, 30(6): 28-36.

陈爽, 黄倩雯, 刘灿, 王彩虹, 王璐瑶, 叶翔宇, 王来力. 废旧纺织品服装回收再利用环境影响评价综述[J]. 现代纺织技术, 2022, 30(6): 28-36.

References

[1] 王来力,吴雄英,丁雪梅.废旧纺织品的回收再利用探讨[J].纺织导报,2009(4):26-28.
WANG Laili, WU Xiongying, DING Xuemei. Investigation on the recycling of waste textiles[J]. China Textile Leader, 2009(4):26-28.
[2] 郭燕.服装废弃阶段的碳足迹评价[J].纺织导报,2013(10):30-32.
GUO Yan. The evaluation of carbon footprint of garment in the abandonment stage[J]. China Textile Leader, 2013(10):30-32.
[3] 郭燕.废旧服装处置方式碳足迹比较[J].棉纺织技术,2014,42(1):78-81.
GUO Yan. Carbon footprint comparison of waste clothing disposal method[J]. Cotton Textile Technology, 2014,42(1):78-81.
[4] 韩非,郎晨宏,邱夷平.废旧纺织品回收体系的研究进展[J].棉纺织技术,2022,50(4):42-48.
HAN Fei, LANG Chenhong, QIU Yiping. Research progress on recycling of waste textiles[J].Cotton Textile Technology, 2022,50(4):42-48.
[5] 韩非,郎晨宏,邱夷平.废旧纺织品资源化循环利用研究进展[J].纺织学报,2022,43(1):96-105.
HAN Fei, LANG Chenhong, QIU Yiping.Research progress in resource recycling based on waste textiles[J]. Journal of Textile Research, 2022, 43(1):96-105.
[6] 赵敏华,杨鹔.废旧纺织品回收利用标准体系建设[J].质量与标准化,2018(7):41-43.
ZHAO Minhua, YANG Su. Construction of waste textile recycling standard system[J]. Quality and Standardization, 2018(7):41-43.
[7] 陈悦,陈超美,刘则渊,等.CiteSpace知识图谱的方法论功能[J].科学学研究,2015,33(2):242-253.
CHEN Yue, CHEN Chaomei, LIU Zeyuan, et al. The methodology function of CiteSpace mapping knowledge domains[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2015, 33(2): 242-253.
[8] ESTEVE-TURRILLAS F A, DE L. Environmental impact of recover cotton in textile industry[J]. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2017, 116:107-115.
[9] 张帆,杨术莉,杜平凡.废旧纺织品回收再利用综述[J].现代纺织技术,2015,23(6):56-62.
ZHANG Fan, YANG Shuli, DU Pingfan. Review on recycling and reusing of waste textiles[J]. Advanced Textile Technology, 2015, 23(6): 56-62.
[10] SANDIN G, PETERS G M. Environmental impact of textile reuse and recycling: A review[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2018:353-365.
[11] 钱蔚然,徐平华,王来力.聚酯纤维回收再利用及环境影响评价进展综述[J].现代纺织技术,2021,29(1):22-26.
QIAN Weiran, XU Pinghua, WANG Laili. Review on polyester fiber recycling and progress of its environmental impact assessment[J]. Advanced Textile Technology, 2021,29(1):22-26.
[12] ZAMANI B, SVANSTRÖM M, PETERS G, et al. A carbon footprint of textile recycling: A case study in Sweden[J]. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 2015, 19(4): 676-687.
[13] FIDAN F S, AYDOGˇAN E K, UZAL N. An integrated life cycle assessment approach for denim fabric production using recycled cotton fibers and combined heat and power plant[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2021, 287:
125439.
[14] LIU Y, HUANG H, ZHU L, et al. Could the recycled yarns substitute for the virgin cotton yarns: A comparative LCA[J]. The International Journal of Life Cycle Assess-ment, 2020, 25(9): 2050-2062.
[15] WIEDEMANN S G, BIGGS L, CLARKE S J, et al. Reducing the environmental impacts of garments through industrially scalable closed-loop recycling: Life cycle assessment of a recycled wool blend sweater[J]. Susta-inability, 2022, 14(3): 1081.
[16] MOAZZEM S, WANG L, DAVER F, et al. Environmental impact of discarded apparel landfilling and recycling[J]. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2021,166:105338.
[17] QIAN W, JI X, XU P, et al. Carbon footprint and water footprint assessment of virgin and recycled polyester textiles[J]. Textile Research Journal, 2021, 91(21-22): 2468-2475.
[18] ROSSON L, BYRNE N. Comparative gate-to-gate life cycle assessment for the alkali and acid pre-treatment step in the chemical recycling of waste cotton[J]. Sustainability, 2020, 12(20): 8613.
[19] PAUNONEN S, KAMPPURI T, KATAJAINEN L, et al. Environmental impact of cellulose carbamate fibers from chemically recycled cotton[J]. Journal of Cleaner Produc-tion, 2019, 222: 871-881.
[20] OELERICH J, BIJLEVELD M, BOUWHUIS G H, et al. The life cycle assessment of cellulose pulp from waste cotton via the SaXcell process[J]. Iop Conference, 2017, 254(19): 192012.
[21] KOLIGKIONI A, PARAJULY K, SØRENSEN B L, et al. Environmental assessment of end-of-life textiles in Denmark[J]. Procedia Cirp, 2018, 69: 962-967.
[22] SUBRAMANIAN K, CHOPRA S S, CAKIN E, et al. Environmental life cycle assessment of textile bio-recycling: Valorizing cotton-polyester textile waste to pet fiber and glucose syrup[J]. Resources Conservation and Recycling, 2020, 161:104989.
[23] AZAPAGICA A, CLIFTB R. Allocation of environmental burdens in multiple-function systems[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 1999, 7(2): 101-119.
[24] ZAMPORI L, PANT R. Suggestions for Updating the Product Environmental Footprint (PEF) Method[R/OL]. [2022-06-09]. https:eplca.jrc.ec.europa.eu/permalink/PEF_method.pdf
[25] 郝彩,王晓蓬,朱紫嫄,等.纺织服装产品环境影响综合评价方法综述[J].染整技术,2022,44(3):1-5.
HAO Cai, WANG Xiaopeng, ZHU Ziyuan, et al. Review on comprehensive assessment methods of environmental impact about textile and clothing products[J]. Textile Dyeing and Finishing Journal, 2022,44(3):1-5.
[26] PUMA Group.PUMA's Environmental Profit and Loss Accountfor the Year Ended 31 December 2010[R]. [2022-06-09]. Germany: PUMA Group, 2011.
[27] 林幼斌,刘春学.影子价格理论及其应用[J].云南财贸学院学报,2001,17(5):50-54.
LIN Youbin, LIU Chunxue. The theory of shadow price and its application[J]. Journal of Yunnan Finance & Economics University, 2001,17(5):50-54.
[28] Sustainable Apparel Coalition.Higg Materials Sustai-nability Index (MSI) Methodology[R]. [2022-06-09]. USA: Higg Index, 2020.
[29] HUIJBREGTS M, STEINMANN Z, ELSHOUT P, et al. ReCiPe2016: A harmonised life cycle impact assessment method at midpoint and endpoint level[J]. International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 2017, 22: 138-147.
[30] DREYER L C, NIEMANN A L, HAUSCHILD M Z. Comparison of three different LCIA method: EDPI97, CML2001 and eco-indicator99: Does it matter which you choose[J]. International Journal of Life Cycle Assess-ment, 2003, 8(4): 191-200.
[31] GEORGAKELLOS D A. The use of the LCA polygon framework in waste management[J]. Management of Environmental Quality An International Journal, 2006, 17(4):490-507.
[32] DANIEL S E, TSOULFAS G T, PAPPIS C P, et al. Aggregating and evaluating the results of different environmental impact assessment methods[J]. Ecological Indicators, 2004, 4(2):125-138.

Review on environmental impact assessment of waste textiles and clothing recycling

废旧纺织品服装回收再利用环境影响评价综述

PDF

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

References

Related Articles 1

Recommended Articles

Metrics